History and semiotics
preliminary thoughts
pp. 77-80
in: Jan Broekman, Francis J. Mootz (eds), The semiotics of law in legal education, Berlin, Springer, 2011Abstract
All historians are semioticians: from an infinite number of occurrences, they select those, which they consider meaningful, hoping to convey the importance of that interpretation to their readers. Even positivists who say history is just a bunch of facts must decide what facts, or the compilers of a chronicle have to choose what to include. Historians thus investigate with some care and sophistication the systems of symbolization, which humankind has developed to give meaning to its existence.The historian does not simply identify symbols but weighs the elements that empower or disable them. Carl Becker showed that even harsh critics of medieval Christianity simply brought Utopia down to earth in some idea and future society. Each of those eras has its own "magic words' or "code" such as God, sin, heaven, grace, and salvation of the Christians, whereas those of the Enlightenment were words nature, natural law, first cause, reason. Charles Sanders Peirce anticipated Becker's way of looking at the world. His theory of history was neglected in his own lifetime. Peirce would formulate insights against social Darwinists: history erupts – cataclysmically.
